Phone: 973-235-1139

Call Today For Catering Inquiries or Questions

Catering For Your Event

Custodi Caterers specializes in custom catering for all types of gatherings: Weddings, Anniversaries, Birthday Parties, Graduation Parties and all types of events.

Corporate Events

Enjoy fantastic food and service at your corporate event. We offer Breakfasts, Lunches and Dinner Packages.

Backyard BBQs

Enjoy time with family and friends this summer and leave the grilling to Custodi Caterers!

Wedding Catering

Our event planner can help you create a beautiful reception at any location.

The Finest in Italian Specialties!

Custodi Caterers located in Nutley, NJ provides gourmet meals for occasions of any type. We offer packages for formal gatherings as well as informal and business catering services.

Thanksgiving 2015 Catering

Order your Thanksgiving Turkey and Sides Now!

Thanksgiving is just around the corner, and this year why not let someone else take care of dinner? Instead, spend your time catching up and spending time with your family, and not worrying about whether the Turkey will be ready in time! Along with our Turkey we offer all of your family favorites including desserts and appetizers. All you need to do is heat and serve. Click the flyer for more information or the link below. Check out our available appetizers, side dishes, and desserts below:


  • Shrimp Cocktail
  • Crab Stuffed Mushrooms
  • Clams Casino or Oreganata
  • Scallops wrapped in Bacon
  • Cold or Hot Antipasto

Side Dishes

  • Mashed Potatoes (Plain, Garlic, Sweet Potatoes, and Buttermilk/Parsley/Bacon)
  • Bacon and Cornbread Stuffing
  • Yams Candied
  • Mixed Vegetables
  • Braised Red Cabbage with Apples
  • Glazed Carrots
  • Broccoli Saute
  • Broccoli Rabe
  • Sausage Mushroom Sage Dressing
  • Cranberry Applesauce
  • String Bean Saute/Almondine
  • Herbed Country Ham
  • Collard Greens


  • Pies: Apple, Apple Crumb, Pumpkin, Coconut Custard, Blueberry, Lemon Merengue
  • Cookie Platters
  • Harvest Baked Apples
  • Mini Pastries
  • Cheesecakes

Click to view sample order form

Contact Us

Custodi CaterersNorth Jersey Preferred Caterer

At Custodi Caterers we provide you with the finest of fresh foods and quality customer service. We are a full-service caterer servicing Northern New Jersey and the Metro New York City area.

We provide catering services for weddings, baptisms, corporate functions, anniversaries, graduations and anytime when food is needed for a gathering! Our event planner is available to answer any questions you might have and help you in planning a special event you will fondly remember.

A Recent TestimonialFrom An Event Attendee

I finally found, right in my hometown, a caterer that is excellent, prepared, courteous and provides quality service.

All the people attending, both local and out of town, were amazed at the type of service and quality of foods you served.

My sincerest and heartfelt thanks to you and your staff for assisting me.

Rest assured I shall utilize your services and also refer you to all seeking the excellent quality you provide

Continued Success,
Louise R. Sivori